Audio Playback Powered by Amazon Web Services  |
Up until recently, if you were looking to design and build a site, the advice that you would get would be to make sure that the layout was aesthetically pleasing, that any graphics you used were crisp and clear, and that the overall design was professional and showed your brand in a positive light.
Yet, somehow, even though those same words are being used and shared over and over, people have begun associating “aesthetically pleasing” with animated and flashy, “crisp and clear graphics” with all graphics all the time, and “overall design is professional and shows your brand in a positive light” as meaning your face and logo absolutely everywhere.
Now of course, there's a time for flashy and animated and all-around obnoxious web design…
It's just probably not on the page you're hoping to get sales on.
And before you come after me on this, some of the most popular websites are far from being beautiful, flashy, or animated.
Craigslist is a great example. It's not the prettiest site, but it's very popular and, most importantly, it works.
Why do sites like Wikipedia, Amazon, and Reddit work so well? They're not fancy, but they're loved and used by many. They focus on being useful and easy to use, not just looking good. It seems that being useful is more important than being pretty.
So, why do these sites do so well? It's because they keep things simple. They don't get caught up in fancy designs. This makes it easier for users to find what they need. And that simplicity can lead to more people taking action.
Key Takeaways
- Ugly websites almost always outperform visually appealing ones in conversions
- Functionality and value proposition are more important than aesthetics
- Simple designs with fewer distractions often lead to better user experiences
- Popular sites like Craigslist and Wikipedia succeed despite basic designs
- Focus on core features and clear navigation to improve conversion rates
Why Ugly Websites Convert Better
It might surprise you, but less attractive websites often do better than the pretty ones. This is because of how they connect with users through conversion psychology and user experience (UX).
The Science Behind Conversion Psychology
Conversion psychology studies how users behave and make choices. Truthaboutabs.com, with its simple design, has a 54% conversion rate. This shows that being effective isn't just about looking good.
Value Proposition vs Visual Appeal
What a website offers is more important than how it looks. 99% of websites (give or take, I'm totally making up this number right now) want to sell something or get users to act in a specific way. It doesn't matter how good your site looks or how flashy the animations are, if people don't like the offer, the site isn't working.
Moreover, if visitors can't figure out what the offer is or what action they need to take, the site isn't working.
The LIFT Model of Conversion
The LIFT model shows six important factors for conversion: value, relevance, clarity, urgency, anxiety, and distraction.
Ugly websites convert so well because they often excel in clarity and avoiding distractions.
They have simple designs and easy-to-follow layouts, leading to better conversion rates.
Websites with too many forms, small buttons, or too much navigation can lower conversions. To improve your site, work on your copy, speed up loading, and reduce clutter. This will make your website better for users and more effective.
The Psychology of Website Design and User Trust
Website credibility is key to gaining user trust.
A confused mind always says no.
Simple designs increase conversions by easing anxiety.
This stat hit me right in the gut: a study revealed that 38% of users will leave if the site looks bad.
But Naomi, didn't you just say that good-looking sites don't convert?? Yeah, I did. Because while we are so worried about this 38% who leave when a site “looks bad”—but what does “looks bad” even mean?
53% of mobile users will leave if a site takes too long to load—so “looking good” clearly isn't just the aesthetic look of a site.
Not only that, but according to a survey by Hotjar, 92% of internet users will leave a cluttered site that is hard to navigate and head over to a competitor.
It's not about the colors and videos and fancy graphics. It's about whether or not people can find what they want quickly and trust you enough to take the next step.
Building trust isn't just about looks.
Sometimes, simple designs make users feel safer. Too many visuals can cause mental fatigue, making sites hard to use.
Clear trust signals are vital. Show contact info, customer reviews, and clear business practices. These elements build trust better than fancy designs.
Simplicity is almost always the best choice—clarity over clever.
Interestingly, how a site looks affects how users see its usability. If a site looks complicated, people will assume it is complicated.
And no one has time for that!
Design Elements That Kill Conversion Rates
Your website's design is key to conversion optimization. Some elements might look good but actually hurt your site's performance. Let's look at these design mistakes and how they affect your site.
Fancy Animations and Load Times
Flashy animations might grab attention, but they slow down your site. Almost half of web users expect pages to load in 2 seconds or less. If your site is slow, users will leave, hurting your conversion rates.
And you want to think about what is grabbing your audience's attention and to what? There's a reason that a site with a big, green button in the header will outperform a site with a video background and no button almost every time.
This actually reminds me of a story from one of my clients. I was brought in to write content for a biohacking and wellness brand back when they were getting ready to launch. I was really excited about this opportunity, and it didn't take me long to develop a content strategy for the site, sales funnels, and email newsletters that was sure to convert. And the best part was that all that hard work was working. I built the email list up to 150,000 contact in under 6 months, and our first wellness challenge brought in over 65,000 participants and over $100,000 in revenue within the first 30 days.
Like any growing company, we brought on new team members, including a new graphics designer who moved the site to a new platform and completely changed the design to match his more flashy, animated persona.
While the site did “look” better, conversions plummeted. Future challenges brought in fewer and fewer participants, merch sales slowed to almost none despite high volumes of traffic, affiliate sales went down, and performance came to a crawl.
And this isn't the only time this has happened.
For 8 years I worked as the marketing director for a popular marketing coach who was rigid on the look of her website. She insisted on certain layouts and colors based on what she found aesthetically pleasing. When I veered away from her color palette (which was 4 shades of light pink accompanied by 4 shades of light gray) and added in more bold colors or even outright “off band” colors like green, those pages would convert much better.
Building a site to suit your version of what “looks good” will almost always kill it for your site's visitors and turn them away.
So, repeat after me: it's more important to build a site that definitely delivers than it is to build a site that I think looks good.
Complex Navigation Systems
Complicated navigation can frustrate users and make them leave. If users can't find what they need quickly, they'll leave, increasing bounce rates.
Excessive Visual Elements
Too many visual elements can overwhelm visitors. Designs with too much clutter or poor color choices can turn users off and lower conversion rates. Too many links, ads, or CTAs can cause choice paralysis, leading to fewer conversions.
Viewers decide to stay or leave in just 5 seconds, and usually before they've even bothered trying to scroll. Focus on clear, simple designs that lead users to your main goals. Avoiding these mistakes can make your website both attractive and effective in conversions.
What about Sites like Apple, which is all Visual Elements?
Okay, yes, Apple has a beautiful, flashy website that follows none of these rules. So why can't you do the same?
Well…to put it bluntly, are you Apple?
Like any rule on the internet, there are always going to be exceptions.
The people going. to Apple's site already know what who Apple is, what Apple offers, and what they want from Apple.
And even then, the Apple homepage is simple, easy to navigate, and not all that animated.
It's not until you get deeper into their site, usually looking at one of their upcoming releases, that things start to get more and more animated and slow-loading. But guess what? They can get away with it because that's what people expect when they think of Apple: innovations and future trends. And, because you got there so easily, you're more likely to stay there and watch the whole thing.
Someone coming to your site for the first time, who doesn't know you from anyone else in your industry, is going to take a lot more convincing before they hang out to watch that video you want on your home page.
And unless you're a graphic designer trying to sell your graphic design services, there's no reason to bury your website in all your graphics.
The Role of Website Speed in Conversions
Website speed is key to your online success. A fast website can greatly increase conversions and keep users coming back. In travel, a 0.1-second speed boost can raise conversions by 10.1%.
This effect is seen across many industries—eCommerce sees an 8.4% increase, and luxury brands get a 3.6% boost for the same speed gain.
If you really want to see just how important your site's speed, take a look at user behavior. Sites that load in 3 seconds or less see 60% more page views. But, a 1-second delay in load time can lead to a 50% drop in visitors and higher bounce rates.
Improving website speed can lead to big gains. Rakuten 24 saw a 33.13% increase in conversion rate after optimizing Core Web Vitals. RedBus saw a 7% increase in sales.
| Load Time | Conversion Rate | Drop in Response |
|---|---|---|
| 1 second | 40% | – |
| 2 seconds | 34% | 15% |
| 3 seconds | 29% | 27.5% |
Speed greatly affects user satisfaction. An extra second can lower satisfaction by 16%. This dissatisfaction can make 40% of unhappy customers less likely to return.
Since 48% of transactions come from returning visitors, you can understand how speed, not flashy looks, is vital for keeping customers.
To stay ahead, aim for load times under 2.9 seconds to rank in the top 20% of fastest websites.
Clarity and User Experience Over Aesthetics
When it comes to website design, clarity and user experience are more important than looks. Your website's success depends on how well it guides visitors to your offes. It should focus on clear content and easy use.
Clear Call-to-Actions
Effective call-to-actions (CTAs) are key for getting people to take action. They should be easy to see and tell visitors what to do to get that offer.
Simplified User Journeys
A smooth user experience keeps visitors interested. This makes for a better user experience and more conversions.
Content Hierarchy
A good content hierarchy makes important info easy to find.
Remember, a one-second delay can cost a big company like Amazon $1.6 billion in sales each year. Websites that load fast and are easy to use do better than fancy but slow ones. By focusing on clarity and user experience, you can make a website that looks good and works great.
So, do you want a website that looks good? Or do you want a website that makes money?
How Minimalism Can Drive Sales
Overall, I am a minimalist when it comes to a lot of things, including web design. So, you can view almost everything I say from the lens of “but yeah, Naomi, you don't like a lot of flash designs so of course you're going to be against them.
And I wouldn't be able to blame you for that. However, just because the statistics happen to play to my personal preferences doesn't make the statistics wrong. I also don't like videos, but I know how great YouTube and TikTok are.
Minimalist web design is a powerful tool for boosting sales because it allows you to focus user attention on what's important. This can significantly increase sales and user engagement.
Think about what they teach you for elevator pitches: can you boil down your offers down to a sentence or two? It's the same concept, just in website form.
Embracing minimalism makes websites user-friendly. It helps visitors focus on key elements, which can increase conversion rates. Studies show that simplifying navigation can lower bounce rates and improve engagement and trust.
Here's how minimalism can drive sales:
- Clear calls-to-action stand out
- Faster page loads improve user experience
- Reduced distractions keep users focused
- Consistent design builds trust
68% of companies with mobile-first web design saw increased sales. This shows the importance of a streamlined, mobile-friendly approach.
| Element | Recommendation | Impact |
|---|---|---|
| Menu Items | 5-7 items | Optimal user experience |
| Colors | 1 main, 2 accents | Effective user guidance |
| Font Faces | 2-3 per page | Refined design |
Each element should have a clear purpose. Try removing unnecessary items and see the effects. This data-driven approach can help you create a minimalist design that boosts sales effectively.
The Balance Between Functionality and Design
I want to point out that when I say “Ugly Sites” I don't mean literal ugly sites. I'm not trying to say you should make your site ugly.
Your site should look great and work flawlessly.
But it doesn't have to have flashy animations, videos, scrolling effects, and other flashy bits to look good.
This balance affects how well your site performs, how users behave, and how many conversions you get.
Performance Metrics
Monitoring performance metrics is essential to identify areas for improvement. A 1-second delay in page load time can reduce conversions by 7%. Fast-loading pages keep users happy and make your site more effective.
User Behavior Analysis
It's important to understand how visitors interact with your site. As I mentioned earlier, 38% of people will leave a website if it's unattractive to them. More people will leave if they can't navigate or if they think it's all too cluttered and busy. By analyzing user behavior, you can make smart design choices that keep visitors engaged.
Conversion Optimization
Improving design elements to boost conversions is an ongoing process. It's worth the effort, as 92.6% of buyers say a website's design affects their buying decision. Regular testing and refinement can lead to significant improvements in your conversion rate.
| Design Factor | Impact on User Behavior | Conversion Rate Effect |
|---|---|---|
| Page Load Speed | Reduced bounce rate | 7% increase per second saved |
| Visual Appeal | 38% less abandonment | Higher engagement |
| Brand Credibility | 75% judge based on design | Increased trust and sales |
The average eCommerce conversion rate is 2.86%. By finding the right balance between functionality and design, you can exceed this benchmark. Focus on creating a visually appealing site that loads quickly and guides users smoothly through their journey.
Social Proof in Simple Designs
Simple designs can be very effective in conversion tactics. By adding social proof, you can increase trust and sales without making your site look cluttered. In fact, 92% of online shoppers trust recommendations more than ads.
Customer testimonials are a big trust builder. They help potential buyers feel sure about your product or service. Research shows that 82% of people read reviews before buying online, and 50% of Americans trust reviews to feel confident in their choices.
- Star ratings: Buyers need at least a 3.4-star rating to trust a business. But, 57% prefer brands with a 4-star rating or higher.
- User-generated content gets 6.9 times more engagement than content from the brand.
- Customer numbers: Show your popularity with “Trusted by over 10,000 customers.”
- Awards and certifications: Display any awards your business has won.
Social proof is a strong tool, but use it right. Stay away from tricks and focus on real customer stories. By adding these to your simple design, you can influence buying decisions and make your brand more relatable and trustworthy.
Also, 70% of customers trust product advice from people they don't know.
So have diverse testimonials that together provide a wide view of your products and services.
Final Thoughts on Why Ugly Websites Convert Better
At the end of the day, a successful website isn’t just about looking good—it’s about doing good. While aesthetics can draw initial interest, it’s the simplicity, functionality, and ease of use that keep visitors engaged and drive them to take action. Sites like Craigslist, Wikipedia, and even Amazon have proven that effective design is rooted in clarity, trust, and performance, not just in looks.
So, instead of focusing on flashy designs, prioritize what truly matters: user experience and clear calls to action. By embracing a minimalist, user-focused approach, you can build a website that not only reflects your brand but also converts visitors into loyal customers. Because when it comes to website development, substance always outweighs style.
Let Me Put Together Your Content Plan!
Unlock the power of strategic, SEO-optimized content with my Done-For-You Blogging Content Maps! Designed to provide a comprehensive, fully tailored content plan, each map is perfectly aligned with your business goals and designed to attract clicks, rank on search engines, and drive conversions.
